by Roberta Sklar
WASHINGTON, D.C. — The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Policy Institute (NGLTFPI) released a report April 4 that exposed the dishonesty of attempts by leaders of the Republican Party to lure black voters based on ‘moral values’ and spotlight the false promises inherent in Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman’s call for African-Americans to come “back home” to the GOP.
The report, “False Promises: How the Right Deploys Homophobia to Win Support from African-Americans,” compared the voting records of key Republican policymakers in Congress to polling of African-Americans’ top voting priorities and found that Republican lawmakers have abysmal voting records on these issues. Authored by Task Force Policy Analyst Nicolas Ray, the report showed that legislators with low ratings on LGBT equality also received low ratings from organizations that promote the rights of people of color, including the NAACP and the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights.
Strange bedfellows
The report outlined the incongruity between historic Republican strategies, including Nixon’s “Southern strategy,” Reagan’s “welfare queens” and George H. W. Bush’s Willie Horton ads, all with disturbing racist undertones, and the Republican Party’s current push for African-American voters to “come home.” The study suggested that the current moral values rhetoric espoused by many in the GOP was designed in part to generate support by stoking homophobia in the African-American community.
“The right wing of the Republican Party has a long-standing record of using fear and bigotry to set Americans against each other for its own gain,” said Matt Foreman, executive director of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. “It is supremely ironic and profoundly sad that this is the party of Lincoln, a party that once sought to unify a nation. It was a party in which ‘freedom’ was a principle, not an empty platitude espoused purely for political gain as is done so often by present-day Republican leaders.”
“This report should be a wake-up call to all black advocates for racial justice and social equality,” said H. Alexander Robinson, chief executive of the National Black Justice Coalition. “We can ill-afford having our voices dissipated by those who would exploit our differences over issues of sexual orientation for their own sinister political gain. Now that their thinly disguised attempts to render our votes meaningless has been revealed, it is up to us rebuild our coalition for change. Poll taxes, literacy tests and lynching didn’t stop us and I am confident we will prevail against this new tactic.”
According to data compiled from polls of the African-American community by the conservative Black America’s Political Action Committee and the progressive Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies (JCPES), top priorities for black voters include economy and jobs; health care and prescription drugs; education; and Social Security. “Moral values” was not a significant concern of the poll respondents.
Despite the Republican Party’s attempt to use LGBT equality as a wedge issue, according to the JCPES poll, 47 percent of African-Americans would support some form of legal recognition of same-sex relationships.
“I’d be excited to see the GOP finally making a serious push for black voters — if the party was offering fresh ideas on police profiling, housing discrimination, unemployment and other issues of importance to black folks. But, the focus (isn’t) on any of that. Rather, it’s on the gosh-darned ‘homosexual agenda,’” said Leonard Pitts Jr., an African-American author quoted in the report.
Conservative Voting Records Is Bad For Blacks
The report outlined the voting records of members of Congress who received the highest ratings from conservative political organizations such as the American Conservative Union and the Family Research Council. All but one of these 125 representatives and 34 senators (a group which includes Sens. Trent Lott and Rick Santorum, and Rep. Tom DeLay) are Republican. The most conservative members of Congress also received some of the lowest ratings from people-of-color rights organizations such as the NAACP and the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights. These legislators also received low ratings from other progressive organizations concerned with LGBT equality, including the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and Americans for Democratic Action.
In addition to these GOP legislators’ sometimes disturbing affiliations with racist organizations such as the Conservative Citizens Council (Lott) and opposition to reauthorization of parts of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (DeLay), people-of-color civil rights organizations were concerned with these legislators’ lack of support for established priorities of the African-American community. These legislators have consistently opposed affirmative action, raising the minimum wage, full funding for education initiatives, including No Child Left Behind, and funding for Medicaid initiatives that disproportionately affect African-Americans.
In addition, the report examined in detail the voting index scores of members of Congress from the six states with the highest proportion of African-American residents — Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi and South Carolina. Republicans from these states consistently scored high on conservative measures, low on indices addressing African-American concerns and near zero on HRC’s measure score of support for LGBT equality. Conversely, while some Democrats managed moderately well with conservative groups, they simultaneously scored much higher on issues of significance to African-Americans, the poor and the LGBT community.
African-American leaders: LGBT rights = Civil rights
Finally, the report pointed to anti-LGBT rhetoric used by religious right figures, including James Dobson, the Rev. Lou Sheldon and Bishop Henry Jackson, as a part of the attempt to bring African-American voters into the Republican Party and spotlighted just how out of step these folks are with major figures of the African-American community, including the late Coretta Scott King, Rep. John Lewis and the NAACP’s Julian Bond.
Rep. John Lewis: “It is time to say forthrightly that government’s exclusion of our gay and lesbian brothers and sisters from civil marriage officially degrades them and their families…this discrimination is wrong.”
Julian Bond, chairman of the NAACP: “There are no ‘special rights’ in America; we are all entitled to life, liberty and happiness’ pursuit. … I see this as a civil rights issue. That means I support gay civil marriage.”
Coretta Scott King: “I appeal to everyone who believes in Martin Luther King’s dream to make room at the table of brotherhood and sisterhood for lesbian and gay people.”
WASHINGTON, D.C. — The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Policy Institute (NGLTFPI) released a report April 4 that exposed the dishonesty of attempts by leaders of the Republican Party to lure black voters based on ‘moral values’ and spotlight the false promises inherent in Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman’s call for African-Americans to come “back home” to the GOP.
The report, “False Promises: How the Right Deploys Homophobia to Win Support from African-Americans,” compared the voting records of key Republican policymakers in Congress to polling of African-Americans’ top voting priorities and found that Republican lawmakers have abysmal voting records on these issues. Authored by Task Force Policy Analyst Nicolas Ray, the report showed that legislators with low ratings on LGBT equality also received low ratings from organizations that promote the rights of people of color, including the NAACP and the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights.
Strange bedfellows
The report outlined the incongruity between historic Republican strategies, including Nixon’s “Southern strategy,” Reagan’s “welfare queens” and George H. W. Bush’s Willie Horton ads, all with disturbing racist undertones, and the Republican Party’s current push for African-American voters to “come home.” The study suggested that the current moral values rhetoric espoused by many in the GOP was designed in part to generate support by stoking homophobia in the African-American community.
“The right wing of the Republican Party has a long-standing record of using fear and bigotry to set Americans against each other for its own gain,” said Matt Foreman, executive director of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. “It is supremely ironic and profoundly sad that this is the party of Lincoln, a party that once sought to unify a nation. It was a party in which ‘freedom’ was a principle, not an empty platitude espoused purely for political gain as is done so often by present-day Republican leaders.”
“This report should be a wake-up call to all black advocates for racial justice and social equality,” said H. Alexander Robinson, chief executive of the National Black Justice Coalition. “We can ill-afford having our voices dissipated by those who would exploit our differences over issues of sexual orientation for their own sinister political gain. Now that their thinly disguised attempts to render our votes meaningless has been revealed, it is up to us rebuild our coalition for change. Poll taxes, literacy tests and lynching didn’t stop us and I am confident we will prevail against this new tactic.”
According to data compiled from polls of the African-American community by the conservative Black America’s Political Action Committee and the progressive Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies (JCPES), top priorities for black voters include economy and jobs; health care and prescription drugs; education; and Social Security. “Moral values” was not a significant concern of the poll respondents.
Despite the Republican Party’s attempt to use LGBT equality as a wedge issue, according to the JCPES poll, 47 percent of African-Americans would support some form of legal recognition of same-sex relationships.
“I’d be excited to see the GOP finally making a serious push for black voters — if the party was offering fresh ideas on police profiling, housing discrimination, unemployment and other issues of importance to black folks. But, the focus (isn’t) on any of that. Rather, it’s on the gosh-darned ‘homosexual agenda,’” said Leonard Pitts Jr., an African-American author quoted in the report.
Conservative Voting Records Is Bad For Blacks
The report outlined the voting records of members of Congress who received the highest ratings from conservative political organizations such as the American Conservative Union and the Family Research Council. All but one of these 125 representatives and 34 senators (a group which includes Sens. Trent Lott and Rick Santorum, and Rep. Tom DeLay) are Republican. The most conservative members of Congress also received some of the lowest ratings from people-of-color rights organizations such as the NAACP and the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights. These legislators also received low ratings from other progressive organizations concerned with LGBT equality, including the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and Americans for Democratic Action.
In addition to these GOP legislators’ sometimes disturbing affiliations with racist organizations such as the Conservative Citizens Council (Lott) and opposition to reauthorization of parts of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (DeLay), people-of-color civil rights organizations were concerned with these legislators’ lack of support for established priorities of the African-American community. These legislators have consistently opposed affirmative action, raising the minimum wage, full funding for education initiatives, including No Child Left Behind, and funding for Medicaid initiatives that disproportionately affect African-Americans.
In addition, the report examined in detail the voting index scores of members of Congress from the six states with the highest proportion of African-American residents — Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi and South Carolina. Republicans from these states consistently scored high on conservative measures, low on indices addressing African-American concerns and near zero on HRC’s measure score of support for LGBT equality. Conversely, while some Democrats managed moderately well with conservative groups, they simultaneously scored much higher on issues of significance to African-Americans, the poor and the LGBT community.
African-American leaders: LGBT rights = Civil rights
Finally, the report pointed to anti-LGBT rhetoric used by religious right figures, including James Dobson, the Rev. Lou Sheldon and Bishop Henry Jackson, as a part of the attempt to bring African-American voters into the Republican Party and spotlighted just how out of step these folks are with major figures of the African-American community, including the late Coretta Scott King, Rep. John Lewis and the NAACP’s Julian Bond.
Rep. John Lewis: “It is time to say forthrightly that government’s exclusion of our gay and lesbian brothers and sisters from civil marriage officially degrades them and their families…this discrimination is wrong.”
Julian Bond, chairman of the NAACP: “There are no ‘special rights’ in America; we are all entitled to life, liberty and happiness’ pursuit. … I see this as a civil rights issue. That means I support gay civil marriage.”
Coretta Scott King: “I appeal to everyone who believes in Martin Luther King’s dream to make room at the table of brotherhood and sisterhood for lesbian and gay people.”
